How to represent "not an empty set"?

$\begingroup$

I'm writing a academic paper and need to represent "A is not the empty set". What is usual way for professional mathematicians?

My idea is:

$|A| > 0$

However, using the emptyset $\emptyset$ might be more intuitive:

$A\ != \emptyset$

But, I know "!=" is not permissible in math community (only in programmers).

Update

Sorry, I fixed the second equation: $|A|\ != \emptyset \rightarrow A\ != \emptyset$

$\endgroup$ 9

6 Answers

$\begingroup$

It is perfectly fine to write $|A|>0$. However, the simplest and most common way to write this in symbols would be $$A\neq\emptyset.$$ Note that you don't want to write $|A|\neq \emptyset$, as it is $A$ itself which you are saying is not the empty set, rather than the cardinality of $A$.

(The standard symbol in mathematics for "not equal" is $\neq$, rather than $!{=}$. You can make this symbol in $\LaTeX$ with the command \neq.)

As mentioned in user21820's nice answer below, though, it is also very common to just write this in words ("$A$ is not empty" or "$A$ is nonempty") instead of symbols.

$\endgroup$ 14 $\begingroup$

None of the other answers so far mention that professional mathematicians don't specially go out of the way to convert everything to symbols. "$A$ is non-empty" is indeed the most common way to express the statement. Furthermore, for complicated structures it is almost always expressed this way, such as:

Given any non-empty chain of fields ordered by inclusion, their union is also a field.

$\endgroup$ 17 $\begingroup$

$A \neq \varnothing$

[LaTeX: A \neq \varnothing]

$\endgroup$ 7 $\begingroup$

$A \neq \emptyset$

Thats how it is commonly written

$\endgroup$ $\begingroup$

How about: $(\exists x)\, x\in A$? Alternatively, one could say that $A$ is inhabited. This usage avoids needless negation which is problematic constructively speaking, and is common in constructive mathematics.

$\endgroup$ 8 $\begingroup$

Let $A$ denote a set.

In constructive mathematics, there's a difference between the statements '$A$ is non-empty,' which is defined to mean that $A$ is not isomorphic to $\emptyset$, and '$A$ is inhabited,' which is defined to mean that $A$ has at least one element, i.e. $\exists a \in A(\mathrm{True})$. Thus, depending on their standpoint and interests, a professional mathematician will probably write one of '$A$ is non-empty' or '$A$ is inhabited.'

Classically, these are equivalent.

$\endgroup$ 2

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Sign up using Google Sign up using Facebook Sign up using Email and Password

Post as a guest

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

You Might Also Like